Casting (30)
Amanda Seyfried
Ann Lee
Lewis Pullman
William Lee
Thomasin McKenzie
Mary Partington / Narrator
Matthew Beard
James Whittaker
Christopher Abbott
Abraham Standerin
Viola Prettejohn
Nancy Lee
David Cale
John Hocknell
Stacy Martin
Jane Wardly
Scott Handy
James Wardley
Jeremy Wheeler
John Townley
Tim Blake Nelson
Pastor Reuben Wight
Daniel Blumberg
Deacon Talmadge Bishop
Willem van der Vegt
Ann's Father
Maria Sand
Ann's Mother
Millie-Rose Crossley
Ann Lee (12 Yrs)
Esmee Hewett
Ann Lee (6 Yrs)
Harry Conway
William Lee (10 Yrs)
Benjamin Bagota
William Lee (4 Yrs)
Scott Alexander Young
Chief Magistrate Tideswell
George Taylor
George Whitefield
Jamie Bogyo
Richard Hocknell
Matti Boustedt
Captain Smith
Alexis Latham
Mr. Cunningham
Shannon Woodward
Mrs. Cunningham
Lark White
Patsy
Roy McCrerey
Mr. Shattuck
Viktória Dányi
Mrs. Shattuck
Natalie Shinnick
Elizabeth Hale
Maddie Browning
Young Mother
Martin O'Regan
Dutchman